The Woody Allen Rule And Debt Collection

Debts are not foreverDiamonds are forever, goes the sales pitch.

If you’ve got bills you can’t pay, it may seem that debt is forever as well.

Not so.  Every debt owed to a creditor who isn’t a governmental entity has a statute of limitations.  That’s the point beyond which a creditor can’t use the law to take money from you.

Far more people can tell you how long a debt can remain on your credit report than can tell you how long a court will help the creditor collect.

The statute of limitations has nothing to do with whether the debt was real.  It simply says that, at some point, all things must pass.  Debt has a life span.  Once it reaches the end of its legal life, you win any lawsuit brought to enforce the debt.

You’ve got to invoke the Woody Allen Rule to win, however.  Allen asserts that 80% of life is showing up.    To win a collection lawsuit when the debt is beyond the statute of limitations, you have to show up,  file an answer in writing and raise that defense.

Put another way:  snooze, you lose.

Finding the statute of limitations

Statutes of limitations are creatures of state law.  Nolo Press has a chart showing the life span of debts in each state and the place in the law where the statute is found.

Generally, the statute that applies is the one in the state where you live or the state where you signed the contract that created the debt.

Calculating the life of debt

You start counting on the statute of limitations from the last activity on the debt.  That could be the last purchase on a credit card, or the last payment on the account.

If you make a partial payment on a long dormant debt, you run the risk of resetting the statute:  the debt may get new life, because there is now new activity.  That’s one of the reasons that debt collectors are so anxious that you make a payment, any payment.

Limits to limitations

Statutes of limitations don’t keep creditors from using methods other than lawsuits to collect the debt .  In fact, the statute of limitations doesn’t prevent the collector from suing.  It just assures that you win if they try to sue.

So debt collectors can continue legally to call and write in an attempt to get you to pay.  That’s zombie debt at work.

So, before you pull out your checkbook to pay on old, old debt, check out the statute of limitations.  That debt may be legally dead.

The FTC summarizes the law on time-barred debts.

Image courtesy of Wikimedia.org

»crosslinked«

Thanks, Diva

Plan finances in decades not months

Diva in Debt highlighted my post on moving beyond month to month financial thinking in this week’s Carnival of Personal Finance. My next goal is to read the other selections in the Carnival and we can compare notes on what resonates. My New Year’s resolution to adopt a 36 hour day never made it off…

How To Chart The Course To Your Financial Future

The Financial Way Forward

  When the path at your feet is full of rocks and puddles, it’s hard to raise your eyes to the horizon. Yet if you watch your feet, you never know where you’re really going. The financial equivalent of watching the path beneath your feet is measuring your finances month to month.  Things are rocky,…

One Man’s Health Concerns Yield Money Saving In The Kitchen

roasting vegetables

I’m an unabashed  fan of NY Times food writer Mark Bittman. My current favorite cookbook is his Best Recipes in the World.  I clip his columns and follow him on Twitter. His New Years article for the NYTimes Mag, No Meat, No Dairy, No Problem, though, resonated with me for its economic implications. For health…

Pocket the Missing Tax

Save the 2% tax cut

On New Year’s, I suggested that instead of a list of resolutions at the beginning of the year, we spread our resolutions out. Make and execute on a resolution a month. Ration the amount of change that we expect of ourselves.  Take small steps, rather than attempt a huge leap. Resolution for January So, for…

New Year, New Ways With Money

No New Year's Resolutions

Welcome to the New Year. My partner in Money Health Central, Jay Fleischman,  says no one is on-line today.  If he’s right, (and he is, sometimes), I’m writing for myself. However, if you’re here, and thinking about what awaits you and your money in the new year, join me in looking ahead to 2012. We’ve…

The True Cost Of “Just Getting By”

living wage calculator

In Bonfire of the Vanities, Sherman McCoy details how he makes $1 million per year and is barely getting by.  The goal of the exercise is to make you sick at the extreme wealth enjoyed by this “Master Of The Universe,” but I remember reading the book as a student and thinking that it’s all…